• On May 8, 2020
    Keith from PA Asked Note: This answer was provided prior to the change to planDisney and may still contain references to Disney Parks Moms Panel.

    Experiences, policies, pricing and other offerings are subject to change and may have changed since the date of this answer.

    Trying to decide between the Polynesian and the Beach Club for our family of four in 2021. Can you give me pros and cons of both? Thx!

    Hi Keith, 

    Welcome back to the Disney Parks Moms Panel! I am so happy to see you here letting us help you with another vacation question. I am also torn between these two resorts for my vacation next spring, so this question is absolutely perfect. Perhaps I can finally decide for myself as I lay out all of the pros and cons of these two fabulous Disney Resorts for you.  

    Both Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort and Disney’s Beach Club Resort benefit from being in excellent locations. I will often try to choose a resort based upon location, minimizing travel time between the resort and parks as much as possible. Both options are conveniently located near a park, Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort being a quick monorail ride to Magic Kingdom Park and Disney’s Beach Club Resort being a short walk from the International Gateway entrance to EPCOT and a short boatride over to Disney’s Hollywood Studios. You also have nearby access to the Disney Skyliner, which will whisk you away on an aerial gondola ride with excellent views. Since Disney’s Beach Club Resort has easy, nearby access to two parks, I say it has the location advantage. Plus you would be a short walk from the restaurants, entertainment and nightlife of Disney’s BoardWalk. 

    Again, both have excellent dining options within or around the resort, but this time I would have to say the advantage goes to Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort, as my utmost favorite restaurant, ‘Ohana, is located there. You also have access to the incredibly delicious Kona Coffee to help get your day started off on the right foot. As if that wasn’t enough, Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort also offers the famous DOLE Whip at Pineapple Lanai. This isn’t to say that Disney’s Beach Club is without excellent dining options, with Cape May Café and Beaches and Cream Soda Shop within the resort and Trattoria al Forno and The Flying Fish nearby at Disney’s BoardWalk, it is still a serious contender. 

    In my opinion, the advantage in theming between the two resorts also goes to Disney’s Polynesian Village, with it invoking tropical vibes and a sense of an authentic island paradise. Though the best resort pool in all of Walt Disney World belongs to Disney’s Beach Club, with Stormalong Bay’s 3-acre aquatic wonderland, equipped with the largest waterslide in any Disney Resort hotel and a lazy river. Ultimately, the decision between these two beautiful resorts hinges upon personal preference. If you are looking to spend most of your time at Magic Kingdom Park, Disney’s Polynesian Village Resort might be the right one for you, though if your plan were to spend a good amount of time in EPCOT or Disney’s Hollywood Studios or around the resort, playing in and around the pool, you would enjoy Disney’s Beach Club Resort tremendously. With both resorts being absolutely wonderful, you honestly cannot go wrong. 

    I hope that this information helps you to select the best possible option for you and your family. Please stop back by any time we can help assist you with your vacation questions. 

    -Angie C. 
thumbnail image for Angie

Meet the Panelist: Angie, Florida

Hi! I'm Angie, an Air Force wife from The Sunshine State! I am so happy to share my love and passion for travel, Disney vacation planning, and the magic of a Disney Vacation Club Membership. My family and I have been enjoying our Vacation Club Membership since 2012 and have discovered a whole new world by taking incredible Walt Disney World vacations, cruises on Disney Cruise Line, and have even made a trip to Disneyland Paris. I would love to help you experience the most magical vacation possible!  Learn More About Angie

Tips from a Disney Vacation Club Panelist

Why a DVC Membership is So Special

view tips

Didn't find what you were looking for? Click the Ask a Question button to open the Ask a Question dialogue box. If you are not logged in a dialogue box will appear to signin in order to ask a question.

To submit your question, please log in now if you have not already done so.

Ask a QuestionOpens the Ask a Question dialog box.

Update Browser

For a better experience browsing this website, please download an updated version of Internet Explorer.

Or you can continue browsing without updating.