Welcome aboard, Lynnell! Your family must have really enjoyed your sailing earlier this year on the Disney Magic!
I know exactly which trophy you are talking about, as my daughter and I won the same thing during "Who Wants To Be A Mouseketeer" on one of our previous sailings too. My daughter is very proud to display her trophy on her shelf in her room. I'm so sorry to hear that your granddaughter's trophy was accidentally thrown out, and I completely understand your wanting to replace it for her.
Unfortunately, that is not one of the pieces of Disney Cruise Line merchandise that is currently available on the Disneystore.com. However, I do have a suggestion for you. You might consider emailing Disney Cruise Line's Guest Communications department. I spoke with an agent at Disney Cruise Line this morning about your situation, and they suggested that you email Guest Communications and let them know about this item. I can't guarantee that they can help replace it, but it certainly is worth asking, Lynnell. Contact them at dcl.guest.communications@disneycruise.com.
If you are unable to replace that exact trophy, I've got a couple other ideas for you. Disneystore.com offers a
Golden Mickey trophy (from the Golden Mickey show onboard Disney Cruise Line's Wonder and Dream ships) that might be a nice gift as a replacement. Alternately, there is a
Disney Magic miniature model which would be a great token to help remember their time on the Magic.
Good luck finding a replacement, Lynnell. And you know, if nothing else, this is a good excuse to book another Disney Cruise. Brush up on your Disney trivia and try your hand at winning "Who Wants To Be A Mouseketeer" on your next sailing too! Good luck! I hope these ideas help!