Hi Steven,
While I have dined at
Be Our Guest for lunch, it will be a few days before I get to dine there for dinner. I wish your question could wait until then but I want to give you my answer now in case you want to adjust your reservation.
The lunch menu at Be Our Guest is sandwiches and salads. The dinner menu is traditional dinner options such as steak, chicken and salmon. It also is a different dining experience from lunch to dinner.
As for
Liberty Tree Tavern, this is not one of my favorite restaurants. The meal is served family style with turkey and all the fixings. However, while other restaurants seem fresh for a meal, this meal seems stale in my opinion. Once the characters left, I have not been back since. It does have the advantage of being on the parade route so if you plan the meal correctly, you can exit dinner and have a spot for the parade.
I would go with Be Our Guest as the menu options are more appealing plus they have the "grey" stuff.
Wishing you a magical vacation!
Beth