Heather,
First of all, start booking right away! With this great deal, table service reservations will get booked up quickly. That having been said, it is hard to know what you prefer in your dining without more info about what you like/dislike, and the nature of your party. But here are a few of my favorite table service meals, by park or resort location;
Magic Kingdom
Crystal Palace
Magic Kingdom Resort Area
Whispering Canyon Cafe
California Grill (2)
'Ohana
Narcoossee's (2)
Chef Mickey's
Epcot
Rose and Crown
Le Cellier
Biergarten
Restaurant Akershus
Epcot Resort Area
Flying Fish (2)
Beaches and Cream
Hollywood Studios
50s Prime Time Cafe
Brown Derby (2)
Mama Melrose's
Animal Kingdom
Tusker House
Yak and Yeti
Animal Kingdom Resort Area
Saana
Boma
Jiko (2)
Downtown Disney Area
Raglan Road
I put (2) next to those that require 2 credits. That is a lot, and I am sure I have more. Why not write me back with some info on what you like and we can hone in on some more specific suggestions!
FYI, the weather will be great then, late September is one of my favorite times to visit!
Have a magical (and delicious) vacation!