Welcome aboard, Andruletta! I am happy to help you break the tie vote between two Disney vacation ideas. Since you came to the cruise moms, you realize that I may be a little biased, but I vote for Plan One: the parks and the cruise on the gorgeous Disney Magic for sure!
If you've never sailed on the
Disney Magic before, you're in for such a different experience than your previous sailing on the Dream. The Magic is smaller, and more intimate, and I actually prefer the two smaller ships because I feel like we really get to take advantage of more of what's offered and get to know the Cast Members around the ship better as there are less guests. Plus, the Magic has some really cool spots and experiences like the AquaDunk! It's way cooler and more exhilarating than the AquaDuck, which I love too, but if you have adventure seekers, they must try the AquaDunk! Plus, you'll have an entire new ship to explore on this sailing, so everything will be brand new!
I, too, am excited about the new attractions at the Walt Disney World Resort, especially
Pandora: The World of Avatar. My family and I will get to explore that new land very soon and we can't wait! I wonder if you might consider one day at Disney's Animal Kingdom to enjoy the new Pandora attractions before you sail, instead of your idea to do Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party? This way, you can enjoy the new attractions AND cruise on a new-to-you ship! However, if it's price that is the sticking factor, it is less expensive to just purchase the Christmas Party tickets instead of a whole day at Animal Kingdom, and I do love all the festivities that Mickey and his pals have in store for guests at Christmastime!
A cruise and a day at Animal Kingdom is my vote! Please stop back if we can help break any other ties!
Marcy