Hello to a fellow Alabamian! I am so happy you are returning to the most magical place on earth! By vacationing in September you will enjoy the parks with very low crowd levels!
I think it is a great idea to try a new resort! You may just find a new favorite. Depending on your party size I would recommend either
Disney's Coronado Springs Resort, or
Disney's Art of Animation Resort.
Disney's Coronado Springs Resort is a moderate level resort, and home to one of my favorite Disney resort pools, the Dig Site! Watch out for the spitting jaquar as you glide down the waterslide.This resort is home to a lovely table service restaurant called Maya Grill, along with the Pepper Market food court. Guests of this resorts have access to the
LaVida Health Club where they can workout, as well as receive relaxing spa services! Standard rooms at this resort contain two queen beds, which will sleep up to 4 guests.
Disney's Art of Animation is a value level resort, that boasts both standard rooms containing two double beds that will sleep 4 guests, as well as family suites that can hold up to a party of 6. You can enjoy the splashtastic activities held daily at the Big Blue Pool, and indulge your tastebuds at the Landscape of Flavors food court. I encourage you to roam around this resort and enjoy all it has to offer, it truly is a work of art.
I hope I have helped make your decision a little easier. If you have any other questions please come back and ask.
Have a Magical Day,
~Jen