Lisa,
Shula's is a VERY high end steakhouse (think Mortons, Ruth Chris, etc.), and expensive. Last time I was there I think my per person bill was over $100. If that sounds like what you guys would do to celebrate, then great. It is very good.
If it seems a bit too high-end, and if the sports theme is a must, then I could recommend the nearby
ESPN Zone. Sandwiches and burgers and a very high-energy atmosphere.
After that there are tons of great places, but not necessarily sports-themed. If you ask me a follow-up question (go to my bio so that you can ask me directly) and tell me about some of his interests, I can make some more informed recommendations. Let me know what he likes to eat, favorite characters, etc.
Look forward to hearing from you!