Hi DeMilo,
Wow! That is a difficult choice! Thanks for allowing us here at the Disney Parks Moms Panel to help you make this decision.
First, let me say that you absolutely cannot select the "wrong" option for your Walt Disney World Resort vacation. While each unique Resort hotel has its own set of benefits, they are all fantastic.
Given the two options that you are considering, I would lean heavily towards 2-Bedroom Villa at
Disney's Saratoga Springs Resort & Spa. While a Club Level stay at any Walt Disney World Resort is certainly an experience to be to be savored, I would actually rather have my own full kitchen that I can stock with our favorite snacks, beverages, and more. Plus, the luxury of space cannot be overstated during a fast-moving vacation. With the ages of your Guests, I would imagine that giving everyone the opportunity to relax and recharge in their own space will be a welcome treat, if not a total necessity.
If you are excited about the convenience of the location of
Disney's Wilderness Lodge, might I suggest a 2-Bedroom Villa in
Bay Lake Tower at Disney's Contemporary Resort to get even closer to the Magic Kingdom Park action? This stunning Disney Vacation Club Resort even offers a third bathroom in the 2-Bedroom Villa to make getting out in the mornings much less stressful. We love it and I think you might as well.
Wishing you many magical memories,
Sally