Hi June,
Another New Yorker! Let me tell you there are lots of options at the Walt Disney World Resorts for every family's budget. Plus with
the buy 4, get three offer, Disney is more affordable than ever!
The All Star Resorts are great! They are a value resort which means they are a good value. However, you will be treated like the movie star, rock star or sport star that compliments their themes. Also, All Star Music has family suites which sleep six and has two toilets which is always a help on vacation.
In the Moderate category, I love Port Orleans Riverside for its Southern charm. It also has quick access to all of the parks via the motorcoach. Caribbean Beach has a great pool and pirate rooms but it is a large resort suited for older children who can handle walking to pools and food.
In the Deluxe, Boardwalk or Yacht and Beach are great locations as you can walk to EPCOT or Disney's Hollywood Studios.
When looking at resorts, the item to consider after price is transportation. While all the Disney transportation is wonderful, standing on a motorcoach with a stroller and a two year old is not my idea of fun. A monorail or boat transportation option might be better. Also, if you are coming back to your resort daily, closer may be better because time is money!
Have a great trip!
Beth