You are right, it is a toss-up! I would have to say that because they both have pretty cool theming, I would opt for the Pop Century. The advantages of the transportation are really significant, and can play a huge role in how much you enjoy your vacation.
Additionally, I think that guests often overlook that the
Pop Century has a few hidden features that the All-Stars don't. The resort runs along side a lake, providing a few unexpected perks. First, it creates a slightly quieter setting,which is important at nap and bed times. It also has a great running trail, and some nice areas to explore on property that
aren't resort themed. Not a lot, but enough to help me choose between the two.
I hope that this helped.
If you have any follow-up questions, feel free to go to my bio page to ask!
Have a magical vacation!