Hi Andrea!
Thank you for visiting the Moms Panel!
All the "Value" Resorts have pools with great theming. What makes the "best" pool is really down to personal preference, and I have outlined below what you will find at each resort.
Guests at Disney's All-Star Resorts (All-Star Movies, Music & Sports) can use the resort pool at any All-Star Resort.
At
All-Star Movies, the main pool has a Fantasia theme. The pools at
All-Star Music are shaped like a giant guitar (the Calypso Pool), or a huge grand piano (the Piano Pool). At
All-Star Sports, Surfboard Bay has an ocean theme.
Disney's Pop Century Resort has pools shaped like a bowling pin, a computer and a flower.
Disney's Art of Animation Resort has 3 swimming pools—a feature pool, The Big Blue Pool, complete with The Drop Off pool bar in the Finding Nemo courtyard, and two smaller pools including the Flippin' Fins Pool in The Little Mermaid courtyard and the Cozy Cone Pool in the Cars courtyard.
If you have any other questions, please come back and ask me - I would be happy to help you plan your magical vacation!