Hi Ashley!
Congratulations on your upcoming honeymoon! I can't think of a better place to celebrate it than at Disney World!
There is something for everyone at Disney World and priorities vary among Guests. Some are very focused on dining and plan out every meal as soon as their window to make reservations opens up. That is fine because there are so many amazing places to eat at Disney that you could literally spend your entire trip eating. I am with you, I personally don't like to plan a whole day out around 2 or 3 dining reservations. I find that when I do, I get too stressed out about making sure I'm there on time or that I might miss out on other things.
I'd recommend making 1 Advanced Dining Reservation (ADR) per day. For your other meals, you can either grab something from a quick service location (there are many good ones) or try walking up to a table service restaurant. I've had good luck walking up to some when there were only 2 in our party & getting a table or being able to sit at the bar.
I have a couple of romantic suggestions for you. Plan one evening at the
California Grill at the Contemporary Resort and make your reservations to coincide with the fireworks.
Narcoossee's at the Grand Floridian is also very romantic and their deck provides an excellent place to view the fireworks at that Magic Kingdom as well.
Wishing you minnie magical memories :-) Allison