Howdy Ashley! I have had so much fun with this question!! Everyone has a favorite!! I love the restaurants you have been to and hope I can add to your mix.
The consensus amongst those I talked to is that Be Our Guest needs to be on your list. If you cannot book a dinner reservation, don't worry. You can enjoy a quick service meal during lunch and I assure you it will be a magical experience.
Disney's Hollywood Studios:
I love The Hollywood Brown Derby. The food is superb and the service is always phenomenal. The grapefruit cake is a must!
Epcot: SO SO many choices!!!
- Teppan Edo has quickly become a family favorite. Teppan chefs prepare your food at your table so your meal becomes a dining experience. Fabulous!
- If you enjoy dining with Princesses, Akershus Royal Banquet Hall is a fantastic option!
- Via Napoli Ristorante e Pizzeria: great food in a wonderful setting!
Downtown Disney:
Wolfgang Puck Express...it's a Quick Service meal with Table Service portions. If you will be on a dining plan and have quick service entitlements to enjoy, I highly recommend Wolfgang Puck Express. In my humble opinion, it's one of the best values on property and the food is wonderful. It fills up quickly but if you can handle a bit of a wait, it's well worth your time.
Disney's Yacht Club Resort:
Yachtsman Steakhouse: similar to Brown Derby. The food and service are exceptional!
I hope this will get you started. Again - thank you! Your question created lengthy conversations amongst family and friends and brought back many magical memories. Please let me know if you need any further ideas and have a magical day!