Hi Jessica,
You're a girl after my own heart, Italian food is my very favorite!
Personally, my family much prefers
Tutto Italia Ristorante over
Tony's Town Square. Tutto Italia serves delicious, authentic Italian food. In addition, the atmosphere is beautiful and the servers are from Italy. It's a lot of fun to talk with them.
We've dined at
Mama Melrose's Ristorante Italiano in Hollywood Studios numerous times as well. While I like Mama Melrose's more than Tony's Town Square, I still prefer Tutto Italia the most.
There is another fantastic new Italian restaurant called
Via Napoli that you may want to try. It is also located in Epcot. Their Neapolitan wood-fired pizza is by far the best pizza I have ever had.
Hope this helps and have a wonderful vacation,
Kaylene