Hi, Lisa!
I simply love using
MagicBands and all the technology of
My Disney Experience. I was not sure how I felt about it at first but I now find that it truly does maximize time in the parks with a bit of planning. However, all this technology does get a bit confusing, especially in cases like yours when you have multiple tickets linked to your MagicBand.
Usually, if you have multiple
tickets, you can stop and any
Guest Relations desk to have your tickets "prioritized" to be used in the order you desire. In your case, it sounds like you want to alternate which tickets are used on different days. Since this is a technical issue beyond what I can assist with, I suggest you call the Internet Help Desk at (407)939-7765. The cast members here are awesome! I have called them with the craziest issues with my personal My Disney Experience account and they always get me all fixed up in a jiffy.
When you call, have all your ticket media handy as well as the email address associated with your My Disney Experience account. Hopefully, with a wave of their magic wands your ticket situation will be simplified easily.
Wishing you a magical vacation!
Cath