Hello Lindsay and thank you for bringing your question to the Disney Parks Moms Panel.
I have such happy memories of staying with my own family at the stunningly beautiful and amazingly themed Disney's Animal Kingdom Lodge so I understand exactly what you mean when asking which Disney Resort can possibly compare!
I believe your dear family might fall in love with the majestic
Disney's Wilderness Lodge; this gloriously rustic Resort is said to be modelled on the
Old Faithful Lodge found in Yellowstone National Park, it is packed full to bursting with delightful details like the huge fire place found in the lobby which is surrounded by old style country rocking chairs.
Guests are spoilt for restaurant choices with 2 x Quick Service, 1 x Fine Dining, 1 x Themed Dining, a lounge bar plus in-room dining options and just look at all these fun r
ecreation possibilities!
Disney's Wilderness Lodge is easily accessible via
Disney Bus Transportation or
Walt Disney World Water Transportation; in fact one of my most favourite boat rides can be enjoyed between Disney's Fort Wilderness Lodge and the Magic Kingdom Park.
I'm sure whichever Resort is finally decided upon you'll enjoy a magical vacation at Walt Disney World Resort making memories with your lovely family which will last an entire lifetime.
Have a great Disney day.
~ Jane