Hi, Sarah!
You have made a wonderful choice with the
All-Star Sports Resort. Larger than life icons that represent all your boys' favorite sports are the center of this super fun resort!
If I were you, my first park would be Magic Kingdom. There are so many family friendly attractions for everyone. Start with attractions like it's a small world, Peter Pan, and the Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh. Once your boys get a feel for what it's like to board and exit attractions, maybe you can try the Tomorrowland Speedway or Astro Orbiter. Other attractions that are friendly include The Magic Carpets of Aladdin and Country Bear Jamboree just to name a few. You will find plenty for them to enjoy!
The second park I would choose would be Disney's Hollywood Studios. They will enjoy Toy Story Mania, Disney Junior - Live on Stage, Lights Motor Action, The Great Movie Ride and more. Since you said they are not into adventure, avoid attractions like Tower of Terror or Rock n Roller Coaster. Click
HERE for a list of attractions. They might have fun dining at Pizza Planet and meeting Lightning McQueen and Mater at Luigi's Garage.
I am confident that your boys will find so much to do, and their wild side just might start to emerge as they begin to enjoy all the great attractions in Walt Disney World! If you are ever in doubt about an attraction, ask the cast member standing outside the queue about the ride, and read posted signs. Have a super time!