Hello Mary Grace and welcome to planDisney!
I love questions where there are no wrong answers! When you are choosing between
Disney's Riviera Resort and
Disney's Polynesian Village Resort, you are going to be the winner! You have also selected my favorite resort, and my middle daughter's favorite! We are always comparing the two resorts and we always come to the same conclusion that we love them both!
I'll start with Riviera, which is my daughter's choice. She has two young sons and the oldest just turned five, so he is in the same age range as your sister's little guy! The Riviera has such a charming, artistic vibe to it that makes you feel like you're relaxing on the French Riviera. The Disney touches certainly remind you that you are in Walt's world, but in a more modern way.
Topolino's Terrace-Flavors of the Riviera is one of the exquisite dining experiences at Walt Disney World. We enjoyed both dinner and the Breakfast a' la Art with Mickey & Friends, and both are amazing! You mentioned the Disney Skyliner access, and it is a wonderful benefit to whisk you to EPCOT and Disney's Hollywood Studios in a flash! The Riviera is beautiful, has a direct connection to multiple theme parks and is a fantastic place to call your Disney home!
Now, if you want classic Disney, let's do the hula and dance over to the Polynesian! The Polynesian was where my family had our first ever Disney resort vacation over 20 years ago! It still holds that special place in all of our hearts! The views of the Magic Kingdom from the beach, the lighting of the tiki torches at night, the smell of the lobby, it all reminds my family of home! My grandsons have spent hours in the Lava pool sliding down the waterslide! There is also a zero-depth entry into the pool for the little guy!
Capt. Cook's is one of our favorite quick service dining spots; my wife and daughters will always order pulled pork nachos at least twice a trip!
Mary Grace, the convenience of the water taxi service across the Seven Seas Lagoon and the Disney Monorail access to the Magic Kingdom make access to the magic so easy from the Polynesian.
I'm a classic, old-school guy. Probably because I'm old! My daughter prefers modern, newer, and more up to date!
So, I think you have two outstanding choices! Mary Grace, whichever resort you choose, I can guarantee you will make memories with your family and have a great adventure! Don't forget to enjoy a Mickey Bar or two!
Kurt