Hello, Susan!
Cape May Cafe is really wonderful place to enjoy a delicious breakfast, especially while staying at Disney's Beach Club Resort.
If, however, you are not interested in a character dining experience, or aren't able to make a reservation, I suggest that you walk a little further and try breakfast at
The Captain's Grille. I stayed at the Beach Club in June and, like you, couldn't be sure of when I'd be able to make breakfast (also, traveling without my family, Character Dining wasn't a must this trip.) Because of the popularity of the Character Breakfast, however, it's tough to find a table without a reservation.
Instead, my Moms Panel buddies Malanie, Wes and I met for breakfast at The Captain's Grille instead, with no reservation, and, frankly, under a really tight schedule. We were seated immediately, welcomed to take advantage of the beautiful-looking buffet and orders taken within minutes. (If you go, try the Lobster Omelet. It was actually tastier than the lobster omelet I ordered while in Maine last month...and it's only $13.49, including a side of roasted potatoes. Yum.)
Have a wonderful trip! Send more questions as you think of them; we love to help!