Hi, Laura! While you will certainly enjoy Cape May, you will be spending a lot of time traveling to get there. After dropping your boys at the Neverland Club at the Polynesian, you will need to take the monorail to the Magic Kingdom and then take the bus to the Beach Club.
You might want to consider some great restaurants nearby: Narcoosees or Grand Floridian Cafe at the Grand Floridian (just one stop away on monorail or short walk from Polynesian,) The Wave or California Grill at the Contemporary (also on the monorail line) or stay right at the Polynesian for The Spirit of Aloha dinner show (luau) or the Kona Cafe.
By staying nearby, you will have more time to discover the 3 monorail resorts, stroll on the beach, and even watch Wishes fireworks from the Polynesian Beach! To see what each of the restaurants has to offer, go to
www.allears.net and click on DINING. You can find each restaurant and look over their menus.
Whatever you decide, make sure to make Advance Dining Reservations by calling (407)WDW-DINE. Also make sure to make reservations for your boys at the Neverland Club when you call for your dining reservation. Enjoy your night out!