Hi Michael,
This is a great question. You are choosing between two resorts that I absolutely love. My family loves
Disney's Animal Kingdom Villas - Kidani Village for the amazing theme, the beautiful decor, and of course, the magnificent ability to walk out on your porch in the morning and see a giraffe. On the other hand, we so enjoy a stay at
Disney's Old Key West Resort. There, it is the relaxed theme and laid-back vibe that we love.
If I had not stayed at either resort, and I knew I was not going to visit Walt Disney World again for a while, I would spend the extra money to stay at Disney's Animal Kingdom Villas - Kidani Village. The experience there is truly unique. If you want to save the money; however, I do enjoy a laid-back vacation at Disney's Old Key West Resort. You just cannot lose in my opinion!
I hope that this helps you in making your decision, Michael. Please do not hesitate to come back and ask if you have any further questions - we would love to help you plan your vacation, whichever resort you choose.