Hello, Gina,
Would you believe I went through this same dilemma just last year? To help me decide, I did look over the menu of both
Citricos and
Narcoossee's and also had my family look over them to get their thoughts of which they would prefer. I also read reviews that are on the independent website Disney Food Blog (www.disneyfoodblog.com), but in the end I couldn't decide so we splurged and ate at both!
If you really have your heart set on seafood, Narcoossee's is a good match. I also really love the views of the water. If you have dining reservations that are later in the evening, you may be able to watch them from your table, too. There is also now a
brunch offering at the restaurant that I haven't tried, but it looks very yummy and a nice option for a fine dining at a different time of day.
So while we did really enjoy dining at Narcoossee's, my family preferred Citricos in the end more. I think a big part of it was that our dining experience was more quiet. We found it pretty noisy at Narcoossee's. We also preferred the food a bit more. However, I do really recommend both of them without hesitation; my family just likes one a bit more than the other.
If we can answer any further questions, please let us know. Happy Disney dining! -
Kara