Hey there, hi there, Laura! Welcome to planDisney. You've brought us a great question and as a fellow Magic Key holder I would love to help get you an answer.
I'm so glad you are planning on renewing your
Magic Key for another year of magic once your renewal window opens. When it comes time to renew your Magic Key it is possible to upgrade your Magic Key to another pass type as long as that pass type is currently available for new sales. Unfortunately, the Believe pass type is not available for new ticket sales or upgrades, only for renewals for those who are already Believe Magic Key holders. That doesn't mean that this couldn't change between now and when your renewal window opens, so just keep checking!
Next time you are in the parks I suggest trying to get a reservation at the
Magic Key Terrace. It's one of my favorite places to take a midday break and check out to see what the latest additions to the menu are. I love getting a table that lets me overlook the park and I love when my reservation time coincides with the sunset so I can catch a glimpse of the Cars Land neon lights all turn on for the night.
Laura, I'm crossing my fingers and throwing out some pixie dust for you so that Magic Key sales open up again for some of the other pass types! See you real soon!
Carrie