Mom And Daughter Magic Kingdom Cinderella's Castle
  • On Jan 11, 2011
    Karieann from WI Asked Note: This answer was provided prior to the change to planDisney and may still contain references to Disney Parks Moms Panel.

    Experiences, policies, pricing and other offerings are subject to change and may have changed since the date of this answer.

    Needing some help!! I am torn between Mama Mel Rose and Tony's Town Square. We haven't been to either place yet. Looks like the same type of food at both places. Which one would you recommend and why? Lunch or Dinner ? Thank you.

    Hello fellow Wisconsinite!

    I like you initial sleuthing on the menus. And while I don't foresee a fight to the finish, I did think a Tony's vs. Mama's point / counterpoint would be a good time. So here we go! 

    Today's match up, featuring...

    Tony's (Magic Kingdom) Mama's (Hollywood Studios)
    Focus is on the ambiance Focus is more on the food
    More run of the mill Italian food More authentic
    Perfectly acceptable to spaghetti kiss Kinda awkward to do the spaghetti kiss
    No alcohol Alcohol
    One of the better options in the park One of several good options in the park
    Harder to get an ADR Easier to get an ADR
    At the very front of the park Deeply embedded within the park
    Has a movie tie-in Has a Fantasmic perk
    Service was speedier Service was more relaxed
    My kids sat through most of the meal My kids didn't last the full meal

    I hope you enjoyed this. I sure did!
thumbnail image for Joel

Meet the Panelist: Joel, Wisconsin

I’m the proud papa of two little pirates or princes (depending on the day!) I enjoy sharing information to help beginners with little ones - including naps, strollers, rider swaps, height restrictions, scary rides, touring plans, characters and dining. Learn More About Joel

Didn't find what you were looking for? Click the Ask a Question button to open the Ask a Question dialogue box. If you are not logged in a dialogue box will appear to signin in order to ask a question.

To submit your question, please sign in now if you have not already done so.

Ask a QuestionOpens the Ask a Question dialog box.

Update Browser

For a better experience browsing this website, please download an updated version of Internet Explorer.

Or you can continue browsing without updating.