Hi there, Allison!
You are absolutely going to LOVE vacationing at Walt Disney World in January! It's one of my favorite months to go! I'm so excited for you! :)
My husband and I recently celebrated our 20-year wedding anniversary and we had the most romantic dinner at
Le Cellier Steakhouse in Epcot's Canada Pavilion. We had a little table for two tucked into one of the back corners and we had such a nice time. We finished eating just in time to step outside and enjoy Illuminations: Reflections of Earth. Our meal was incredibly delicious. If you and your hubby enjoy a great steak, this is the place! And try the "Le Cellier" Lobster Chopped Salad, it's the most wonderful salad on the planet!
Another restaurant that my husband and I just love is
Narcoossee's located right on the waterfront of Disney's Grand Floridian Resort & Spa. The atmosphere reminds me of Prince Edward Island in Canada! The food is out of this world! My very favorite part about it is that when it's time for Wishes nighttime spectacular, you can leave your table and go outside to the deck! The music is piped in so it feels like you're right there. I really love this vantage point and it's very romantic to stand out by the water and watch the fireworks.
I hope that helps! After you've made your decision, I would make the reservations right away and still keep checking California Grill if you have your heart set on dining there. You just never know!
Thanks so much for sending your question my way, Allison! Please let me know if I can help with any others!
Wishing you a Pixie Dusted Anniversary!
~Jackie