Hello Angela, on behalf of the Disney Parks Moms Panel, I would like to wish you and your husband a very happy anniversary. What better way to celebrate than in the place where fairy tales come true. I am also glad to hear that you are trying out a new resort. It is always great to explore all that Walt Disney World Resort has to offer.
I have been Disney's Caribbean Beach Resort many times and my favorite area to stay in is Jamaica and more specifically in building 45. This building is adjacent to the bridge that takes you over to Old Port Royale Centertown. This is the main building that houses the dining locations, including
Shutters at Old Port Royale and the food court, which offers a wide variety of menu options. The main pool, Fuentes del Morro, is right next to it. Also nearby is Barefoot Bay. Here you can
rent surrey bikes. This might be a fun and romantic way to spend an afternoon together. So, if you are looking for a location that is directly next to Old Port Royale Centertown, then I would also recommend building 26 in Martinique or building 31 in Trinidad North. Both of those buildings are also very close to the bus stop for transportation to and from the parks.
When making your requests for specific buildings or a king bed, please keep in mind that those requests cannot be guaranteed and are based on availability upon arrival. Don't forget to ask for your anniversary celebration buttons when you check-in. Your trip will be here before you can say "supercalifragilisticexpialidocious"! May your "happily ever after" be all you wished for.
~Allison L