Hi Julie,
Well, you are on a great start with the potential dates you have chosen. Traveling during either of those two times are fantastic opportunities for some unique experiences.
I, personally, enjoy
MIckey's Not So Scary Halloween Party the best. With the Boo to You Parade, HalloWishes (special nighttime spectacular unique to party evenings), trick or treating, meet and greets with some of your favorite characters dressed in their Halloween costumes, and fun and lively dance parties, I'm sure kids of any age will enjoy all there is to offer. Plus, you can dress up along with your kids and have loads of family fun to cherish for years to come!
Don't get me wrong,
Mickey's Very Merry Christmas Party is absolutely wonderful and has unique holiday magic all its own. It snows on Main Street, you can meet Santa, and enjoy complimentary holiday cookies and hot cocoa. The parade even has special touches that you won't find at any other time...think aromas of the holidays.
I hope you are able to choose the perfect time to go based on your families likes and dislikes. Have a magical trip and feel free to stop back by with more questions as you continue to plan.
~Allison L