Hello Tara,
It is very hard to recommend one certain restaurant at Walt Disney World, there are so many wonderful choices, so I will go ahead and just give you a few of mine. First, I would suggest the "
Coral Reef Restaurant" located in Epcot at The Living Seas Pavilion. I have included this one in many of my answers to other guests, since this one has an absolutely amazing atmosphere (in my opinion) as well as many other 5 star menu choices. I have had the NY strip steak here a few times and found it always very tender while full of flavor, and the desserts (OH BOY!!!!!).
My second choice would be the "
Kona Cafe" located in the Polynesian Resort (complete Hawaiian experience). I had the Filet Mignon here, and oh my gawrsh! talk about "melt in your mouth" I am not kidding, some of the best I have ever had!!! (wonderful coffee here as well!).
Lastly, I have to suggest the Buffalo Steak in "
Artist Point" located at the Wilderness Lodge Resort (complete rustic outdoor experience, but "inside"). I had this particular steak on my most recent trip in December, and the server suggested getting it done Medium Rare or Medium. I chose the Medium and she was absolutely right, (you would think "gamy" right? "au contraire mon ami") not at all gamy, a little sweet and very tender (along with a Pina Colada, even better!).
I hope this helps you and I 'm sure whichever choice your friend makes her dad will enjoy his birthday surprise!
Best wishes,
Brigitta