Ahoy there Julie,
Sounds like you've got some little buccaneers ready for some swashbuckling fun! Those are 3 great options to choose from but if I had to choose one, The
Pirates and Pals Fireworks Voyage would get my vote. One reason is because its something that your whole family can participate in. The Pirates League has a minimum age requirement of 3 years old. Disney's Pirate Adventure is for kids ages 4 - 12. This trip, you can do Pirates & Pals and try the other two when all three of your kids are old enough to enjoy them so that your little one isn't left out.
One awesome thing about the Pirates and Pals Fireworks Voyages for families with younger kids is being able to see the fireworks without being elbow-to-elbow in a sea of people in the Magic Kingdom. If the loud noises from fireworks bother younger kids, this experience allows them to enjoy it with a great view but without the loud booms. You get to relax and watch them from one of the best viewing spots ever. I loved watching the fireworks over the water - it was just beautiful!
I think people of all ages will enjoy Pirates and Pals, especially if you've never done it. I'm one of those people that likes to try everything at WDW at least once. Click
here to see a video of some of the Moms Panelists on this experience.
If you want to try to book a voyage, I'd recommend that you try now by calling 407-WDW-PLAY. If you have any other questions about the Pirates and Pals Fireworks Voyage, let me know - I'm happy to help!
Wishing you many magical memories :-) Allison