Hi Emily! It sounds like you are planning an awesome vacation! The good news is, I think no matter what you select for your dining - you will totally enjoy it. As far as dinner shows, I just love the
Hoop-Dee-Doo Musical Revue! If you are looking for fun (and a little corny!) this is the place to be! The
signature dining locations are a special treat. A couple of my favorites are California Grill (try to time your reservation so you are there for Wishes), Citricos and Le Cellier. One that I thought I would not enjoy but it turned out to be my absolute favorite is Jiko. I also dined at Monsieur Paul last month and that was wonderful as well.
As a thought, you may want to visit the disneyfoodblog.com and read through some of the reviews but again, try not to stress about this too much as no matter what you select, you will be fine.
Have a wonderful vacation with the girls, Emily!