Hi Tonya,
I do not see any reason why you shouldn't be able to upgrade your 9 day Magic Your Way theme park tickets to Annual Passes once you arrive at the Walt Disney World Resort (regardless of whether you have received free dining as part of your Magic Your Way Vacation Package, or not).
Annual Passes have
additional benefits, such as special discounts, that can make them great value.
According to the
Tickets - Frequently Asked Questions section of the Walt Disney World website, if it is within 14 days of a Magic Your Way theme park ticket’s first use and the ticket has remaining admissions, you are able to upgrade the ticket. If it is more than 14 days after first use or if no admissions remain, then a ticket may not be modified or upgraded.
Please do note that ticket upgrades must be made in person at any of the following locations at Walt Disney World Resort:
•Ticket windows at theme parks and water parks
•Concierge desks at Disney Resort hotels
•Guest Relations at the Disney Springs Area
Wishing you a magical trip filled with memories which will last a lifetime!
Emma