Hi Julie and happy anniversary!! I think you will love Cirque du Soleil, it is an absolutely breathtaking show that just leaves you in awe. Having been to both Fulton's Crab House and California Grill and thoroughly enjoying both, I'd have to go with California Grill for an anniversary dinner. Fulton's is beautiful and has excellent food, but it's pretty hard to beat the view at California Grill, especially during the Wishes fireworks. Add to that the simply amazing food at California Grill and you have a wonderfully romantic night in store.
Check out the menu at
Fulton's Crab House and
California Grill and make sure you are choosing the right place for your palate, but I think for ambiance, view and overall experience, California Grill is the best choice.
I guess if I had to choose a con, it would be that if you are going to Cirque du Soleil on the same night, it will be a longer commute to get over to California Grill and you'd probably have to decide to see the show or Wishes since
La Nouba performs at 6 and 9pm, and Wishes usually runs at 9pm or earlier if the
Magic Kingdom closes early. Keep that in mind as you plan and if you have any other questions just let us know!
Have a wonderful anniversary celebration!