Hello, Salina!
Welcome to planDisney, I'd be happy to help you with your Magic Key question. I'm so sorry that your "Happily Ever After" hasn't found you quite yet! Sometimes you get a Hans instead of a Kristoff, but I'm sending TONS of pixie dust and happy thoughts your way.
Being a
Magic Key holder means there is a special phone line, just to help you! As a California resident making monthly payments, you should call Magic Key Monthly Payments Guest Services at (800) 410-4656 Monday through Friday from 8:00 a.m. to 8:00 p.m. Pacific Time. Hopefully, they will be able to help you assign a separate payment method for each Magic Key.
I know that many Magic Key passes are currently blocked out or limited for the summer, but I highly recommend taking a trip to the Downtown Disney District for an evening out! You're still welcome to use your
Disneyland Resort Magic Key Discounts to shop and dine through the district, even when you're not going inside the parks. A trip to
Beignets Expressed would be at the top of my list!
I hope something magical is just around the corner for you, Salina!
Keep moving forward!
Amanda