Hi
Jolene!
The thing to keep in mind when reading restaurant reviews is that they are highly subjective. I too hesitated to make reservations at this Disney dining location the first time we visited. However, my family and I have enjoyed dinner at Epcot's
Coral Reef Restaurant and I can tell you we thoroughly enjoyed our meals there. My 11 yr. old daughter, who orders her food off the adult
Dinner Menu, is asking me to go back to the Coral Reef Restaurant on our next trip to Disney!
I would recommend the Crispy-fried Shrimp as an appetizer and the Grilled Mahi Mahi for your main course. The Chocolate Wave dessert is to die for! Best of all, you can't beat the view! You'll be surrounded by stunning underwater views of the Caribbean Coral Reef at Epcot! So I would say keep your reservation at the Coral Reef Restaurant this time, and try the Seafood Buffet at
Cape May Café next time! Please let me know if I can answer any other questions for you.
Enjoy a most magical visit to the Walt Disney World Resort!